Most people who get hurt in a car accident on I-94 near Bismarck, or out on Highway 83 heading north toward Minot, are not thinking about lawsuits. They are thinking about their next doctor’s appointment, whether they can afford to miss more work, and how they are going to explain all of this to their family. That is completely understandable. But at some point, the question comes up: is taking legal action actually worth it? Honestly, it depends on the situation, and the answer is not always the same for everyone.
North Dakota has its own set of rules that shape how car accident claims work, and those rules affect whether a lawsuit makes sense for your situation. For people injured in collisions involving passenger vehicles, commercial trucks, or other motor vehicles, understanding those rules early can make a real difference in what options are available to you. Our attorneys handle car and truck accident cases throughout North Dakota, northern South Dakota, and eastern Montana, and we see firsthand how the details of each case determine the right path forward.
What Can You Actually Recover From a Lawsuit?
North Dakota is what is called a no-fault insurance state. That means after a crash, your own Personal Injury Protection coverage, commonly called PIP, pays for your medical bills and a portion of lost wages regardless of who caused the accident. PIP coverage in North Dakota is required to go up to $30,000 per person. For minor injuries, that coverage may be enough to get you through.
But PIP does not cover everything. Pain and suffering, permanent scarring, long-term disability, and other non-economic losses are not part of the no-fault system. To recover those damages, North Dakota law requires that your injuries meet what is called a tort threshold. Specifically, your accident-related medical bills need to exceed $2,500, or your injury must involve serious and permanent disfigurement or a disability that lasted longer than 60 days. If your situation meets that threshold, you may have the right to pursue a claim directly against the at-fault driver for the full range of your losses.
So what does that actually look like in terms of money? A personal injury lawsuit could potentially allow you to seek compensation for medical expenses beyond what PIP covered, lost income, reduced earning capacity going forward, physical pain, emotional distress, and more. We have seen clients in situations where those numbers add up to figures that made a very real difference in their financial recovery. There is no guarantee of any specific outcome, but the potential value of a lawsuit is often far greater than what an initial insurance offer reflects.
When Does Filing a Lawsuit Make the Most Sense?
Strong cases tend to share a few common features. Serious injuries are the clearest indicator. Broken bones, traumatic brain injuries, spinal damage, injuries requiring surgery, and conditions that keep someone out of work for weeks or months, these are the situations where the gap between what insurance pays and what someone actually lost can be substantial.
Cases where fault is clear also tend to be stronger. A rear-end collision on I-94 near Mandan, a driver who ran a red light at a Bismarck intersection, a crash caused by someone driving while impaired, these are situations where establishing liability is more straightforward. When the evidence is solid and the injuries are real, a lawsuit is often worth pursuing.
Wrongful death cases are a different matter entirely. If you lost a family member in a crash caused by another driver, the timeline is significantly shorter. North Dakota law generally requires a wrongful death claim to be filed within two years of the date of death. That window moves faster than most families expect, especially while they are still grieving. If you are in that situation, please do not wait.
When a Lawsuit Might Not Be the Right Move
Frankly, not every accident leads to a lawsuit worth filing. If injuries were minor and resolved quickly, if medical costs stayed well below the tort threshold, and if the at-fault driver’s insurance company is offering a fair settlement that genuinely covers your losses, going to court may not add value. Litigation takes time, and for smaller claims, the process may not be the most practical route.
North Dakota also follows a modified comparative fault rule. To clarify that point, if you were partly responsible for the accident, your compensation may be reduced by your percentage of fault. And if you are found to be 50% or more at fault, you may not be able to recover anything at all. Cases where shared fault is a real issue require careful evaluation before deciding whether to file.
The thing about North Dakota winters… actually, let me back up. Weather-related crashes on roads like Highway 2 near Williston or stretches of I-29 in the eastern part of the state often involve questions about road conditions, driver decisions, and shared responsibility. Those cases can be more complicated, and the fault analysis matters a great deal.
You Do Not Need Money to Hire a Car Accident Lawyer
One of the most common reasons people hesitate to call a lawyer is the assumption that they cannot afford one. In North Dakota, personal injury attorneys, including our firm, typically work on what is called a contingency fee basis. What that means in plain terms is that you pay no attorney fees upfront and no hourly billing. The attorney’s fee comes as an agreed percentage of whatever is recovered for you, whether through settlement or a court verdict. If nothing is recovered, you owe no attorney fee. That structure exists so that injured people can access legal representation regardless of their financial situation.
We serve clients throughout Burleigh County, Morton County, and the broader region, including residents of northern South Dakota and eastern Montana who were injured in crashes that crossed state lines or involved North Dakota roads. If you are unsure whether your situation warrants a lawsuit, a conversation with our team costs you nothing and comes with no obligation. Reach out to Schweigert, Klemin & McBride, P.C. in Bismarck and let us take a look at what happened.