Who Is Liable for Injuries on Oilfield Work Sites in North Dakota?

Home » Oilfield Accidents » Who Is Liable for Injuries on Oilfield Work Sites in North Dakota?

Working the Bakken is not like most jobs. Out in McKenzie County, Williams County, Mountrail, and Dunn, the rigs run around the clock, the roads carry constant truck traffic, and the margin for error on any given shift can be razor thin. When something goes wrong out there, the injuries tend to be serious. Burns, crushing injuries, falls, equipment failures. These are not minor incidents.

If you or someone in your family has been hurt on a North Dakota oilfield work site, one of the first questions people ask is: who is actually responsible here? That question has a real answer, but it is more layered than most workers realize. Our oilfield accident attorneys at Schweigert, Klemin & McBride, P.C. work through this with clients regularly, and the short version is this: you may have more than one avenue for recovery, and understanding both matters a great deal.

North Dakota Workers’ Compensation Is Different From Most States

Most injured workers know about workers’ compensation. What many do not realize is that North Dakota runs its system differently than almost anywhere else in the country.

North Dakota is one of only four states in the U.S. with an exclusive state workers’ compensation fund. That fund is called Workforce Safety and Insurance, or WSI. WSI is an exclusive employer-financed, no-fault insurance system covering workplace injuries, illnesses, and death. North Dakota law does not allow private insurers to underwrite workers’ compensation insurance in North Dakota. So unlike states where your employer might carry a private policy, every workers’ comp claim in North Dakota runs through WSI.

North Dakota’s workers’ compensation law, with limited exceptions, requires all employers to insure all employees including full-time, part-time, seasonal, and occasional workers before employees begin working. That coverage kicks in without needing to prove anyone was at fault. Workers’ compensation covers all reasonable, medically necessary treatments to help injured workers heal, including surgeries, medications, and physical therapy. Wage-loss benefits provide partial income replacement for injured workers while they are kept off work by their doctor.

In simple cases, this system can work reasonably well. But oilfield injuries are rarely simple.

What Workers’ Compensation Does Not Cover

This is where things get important. WSI benefits are genuinely helpful for covering medical bills and replacing a portion of lost wages. However, workers’ compensation only covers a portion of an injured party’s medical bill and lost wages. WSI does not cover general damages such as pain and suffering, disfigurement, or mental anguish.

Think about what that means for someone who suffers severe burns at a Watford City well site, or a crushing injury from equipment failure on a drilling rig near Williston. The physical pain, the emotional toll, the long-term impact on quality of life. None of that is compensated through WSI. Workers’ compensation does not cover the full cost of your lost income, nor does it provide benefits for non-economic losses, such as pain and suffering.

And another thing worth noting: WSI, working with the employer, often cuts off benefits long before the injured worker has been fairly compensated. We have seen this happen. The system is designed to be efficient, not necessarily generous.

Third-Party Liability: The Piece Most Workers Miss

Oilfield work sites are not simple one-employer operations. On any given site near Stanley or Dickinson, you might have the well operator, multiple drilling contractors, service companies handling cementing or well control, equipment vendors, trucking companies, and more. High turnover, long shifts, and the difficulty of coordinating work between multiple contractors on-site simultaneously all contribute to the workplace hazards.

When a worker is hurt, the employer is typically shielded from lawsuits through the workers’ comp system. The workers’ compensation system is a no-fault program that was put in place as a bit of a compromise between employers and employees. Employers would pay for insurance that would cover employees who got injured at work in exchange for not having to defend lawsuits every time a worker got injured on the job. That trade-off is baked into the law.

But here is what changes the picture entirely: if someone other than your employer contributed to the accident, a separate legal claim may be available. An often-overlooked remedy in workplace injury situations is what the law refers to as “third-party liability.” Third-party liability is triggered when another party, other than the employee or employer, negligently contributed to the accident. In the oil field, these are generally independent contractors or third-party servicers.

Who might that be? Oilfield operations often involve multiple companies and contractors. Responsibility for accidents can fall on parties other than direct employers, including equipment manufacturers who provide faulty tools or machines, and landowners who fail to address hazards on the oilfield properties. Service companies, subcontractors who created unsafe conditions, and even supervisors or managers whose decisions contributed to the accident may also carry liability in certain circumstances.

How a Third-Party Claim Works

Unlike a WSI claim, a third-party liability claim goes through the civil court system. Third-party liability claims are brought in state court. This is generally through a negligence action in which the injured party needs to show that the third party had a duty to behave in a reasonably safe manner, that they breached that duty, that the injured party actually suffered an injury or damages, and that the third party was responsible in whole or in part for those injuries.

Proving negligence takes real work. Evidence from the accident scene matters. Safety records matter. Equipment inspection reports matter. Witness accounts matter. Most people hire lawyers too late. By then, half the evidence is gone and the site has been cleaned up or modified. We encourage clients to reach out as early as possible after an injury, precisely because building a strong third-party claim depends on what gets preserved in those early days.

What can a successful third-party claim recover that WSI cannot? Recoverable damages may include full lost wages, including overtime and future earning capacity, not just the partial wage replacement WSI provides, pain and suffering, which workers’ comp does not cover at all, and all past and future medical expenses related to the injury. A successful claim could also cover losses in future earning capacity if your injuries prevent you from returning to the same type of work. Additionally, unlike workers’ comp, a third-party claim payout could compensate you for physical pain and emotional distress related to your injury.

To clarify one point that comes up often: you can generally pursue both a WSI claim and a third-party lawsuit at the same time. They are not mutually exclusive. The injured worker may have the right to pursue a personal injury lawsuit against the at-fault third party while still receiving workers’ compensation benefits. There are some interactions between the two that need to be managed carefully, but that is what legal counsel is for.

The Statute of Limitations Question

About those filing deadlines. They matter more than most people realize, and the timelines differ depending on which type of claim you are pursuing.

For workers’ compensation, any injured oilfield worker should report their injury to their employer immediately, preferably within 24 hours if possible. Injured workers must also file a workers’ comp claim within one year of their injury to avoid losing their benefits. That one-year window can close faster than people expect, especially when someone is focused on recovering from a serious injury.

The timing here is CRITICAL. Missing a filing deadline in North Dakota can eliminate your options entirely. We strongly encourage anyone injured on an oilfield work site to connect with an attorney before those windows close, not after.

The Danger Picture in the Bakken

North Dakota’s oilfield injury numbers are not abstract. North Dakota consistently ranks as one of the most dangerous states for workers, and the oil and gas industry bears much of the responsibility. The AFL-CIO has named North Dakota among the deadliest states to work in, with oilfield injuries and fatalities driving those statistics.

Industry analysts and OSHA officials note that falling crude oil prices may have driven oil companies to hire less experienced contractors, relax safety training and standards, and push workers to work in unsafe conditions. That pattern, when it leads to a serious injury, is exactly the kind of conduct that can support a negligence claim against the responsible party.

This reminds us of a broader point that applies across many types of injury cases: the law provides clear answers in theory, but the real-world application requires judgment about which parties contributed to the harm and in what proportion. Oilfield cases are particularly complex because of how many entities operate on a single site. Even experienced practitioners sometimes disagree on the best approach when multiple contractors and subcontractors are involved.

What You Should Do After an Oilfield Injury in North Dakota

Seek medical care first. Document everything you can. Report the injury to your employer promptly. And then connect with an attorney who understands how oilfield liability works in this state.

At Schweigert, Klemin & McBride, P.C., we serve clients across western and central North Dakota, including in the counties where oilfield work is concentrated. If you or a family member has been injured on an oilfield work site, we are glad to talk through your situation and help you understand what options may be available. Reach out to us for a consultation. The earlier we can connect, the better positioned you will be.

Recent Post
Archives
Archives
Categories
Categories